The battle lines are drawn in the Premier League’s transfer arena as Manchester United and Tottenham Hotspur vie for the signature of Jarrad Branthwaite from Everton.
According to a report from Football Talk, the 23-year-old centre-back is drawing interest from both clubs in a potential summer move.
Branthwaite’s current situation at Everton
Branthwaite emerged from the youth ranks of Carlisle United and joined Everton in January 2020. Over recent seasons, he has established himself as one of Everton’s key defensive assets, valued for his all-round defending, aerial ability, and composure on the ball.
Everton moved to lock down his future in July 2025 when he signed an extension through to June 2030. That long contract complicates any transfer move, as his club clearly regards him as central to their rebuild.
Why Manchester United wants him
At United, the need for defensive renewal remains pressing. With uncertainties over existing centre-backs and the club looking to build a stronger base under their new direction, Branthwaite ticks many boxes: young, left-footed, Premier League proven, and with potential for many years at the top level.
The Football Talk piece says United view him as a “key figure in their defensive overhaul”. In short, United sees him as part of a long-term solution.
Why Tottenham is also in the race
Tottenham, meanwhile, is chasing defensive reinforcements and has identified Branthwaite as an ideal fit. Reports suggest manager Thomas Frank’s plan includes the acquisition of a left-footed centre-back, and Branthwaite matches the profile.
The fight is not just about ability — it’s about supply/demand, as Tottenham seek to keep pace with rivals while restructuring their defensive base.
Contract & valuation issues
While both clubs are interested, the stumbling block appears to be valuation. Everton is holding firm, with figures of around £70 million plus linked to Branthwaite’s price tag.
That sum poses a major investment and could force one or both clubs to decide whether this is their top target or whether a slightly cheaper alternative will offer better value.
What this could mean for all parties
For Everton, retaining Branthwaite would signal confidence in their future, but letting him go would be a significant loss.
For United and Spurs, landing such a talent would strengthen their defences — but only if they are willing to meet the price. The next window could see one of the Premier League’s most sought-after defenders make a major move — or stay put at Goodison Park.